no one is going to waste time on kacsmar who is a known Pats hater lol
and the stats he's pulling out of his ass don't mean anything, we've heard these arguments a million times... Colt fans were obsessed with PEDton Manning's stats and used that as some sort of "proof" that he was a better QB than Brady, claiming Brady was just lucky to be on a winning team
Brady got labeled a "dink and dunker" despite leading the league in air yard/completion several times, and at one point had 2 of the top 3 highest scoring offenses in NFL history (2007 with Moss, 2010 with Gronk/Hernandez)
he also ignores all the talent Mahomes had around him.. same thing Colts fans did, they ignored the 2 hall of famers in reggie wayne and marvin harrison, they ignored all the 1st round picks used on RBs like Joseph Addai, offensive lineman, tight ends like Dallas Clark, etc.. Mahomes had hall of famer in Kelce and Tyreek Hill, and they've surrounded him with other great weapons as well.. Rashee Rice was a high round draft pick, they went out and got him JuJu Smith one year, they got him Sammy Watkins, they drafted Mecole Hardman, etc and his coach is arguably one of the greatest offensive minds in NFL history (same coach that got Donovan McNabb to 4 NFC Championships in a row)
One year 4 of Manning's 5 offensive lineman made the pro bowl... he played in a dome 9 times minimum a year (8 at Indy, 1 at Houston)
Then the media started deep throating Aaron Rodgers.. they annointed him the most talented QB in the history of the league...
now they're doing it for Mahomes.. after Brady retired, and there is no one else left in the league that is elite caliber QBs... so Mahomes is in one of the easiest QB eras in the history of the league right now
trying to elevate him above someone who has more than double his rings, countless historic moments, etc 1 year after they retired and are no longer in the picture to fuck Mahomes world up like Brady was doing... is lame and desperate as fuck
no one will respect the argument because its stupid to be making the argument right now.. and quoting a notorious Pats hater over and over again isn't going to change that