Patty Mahomes GOAT

Not MaGOAT fault he takes advantage of free plays. Just shows the other QBs don't have the balls
The balls of the Refs in his mouth
 
What I hear is excuses.

Brady played in a playoff game with the flu.

Brady played a Superbowl with a fucked up thumb

Brady played a Superbowl with his top pass catchers either hobbled or out with injuries.


He still won 7 super bowls and did not get blown out in any of the losses. Mahomes hasn't done shit.
Brady has, effectively, THREE Hall-Worthy careers. Split his regular seasons into two careers and he's still a god. Take his playoff career on its own and he's still a god.
 
Chefs need to get their LT situation taken care of. That rookie who's name I'm not even going to google has been awful.
 
Chefs need to get their LT situation taken care of. That rookie who's name I'm not even going to google has been awful.
They'll figure it out. In Veach we trust
 
*Yawn*
Mahomes just is better the better you realize that the easier it'll be for you to accept when he takes the GOAT mantle in a few years
Rings hollow.
 
*Yawn*
Mahomes just is better the better you realize that the easier it'll be for you to accept when he takes the GOAT mantle in a few years


Brady destroyed him in the playoffs. Mahomes is just another "He's great, but..." guy. And that's ok, because there are a lot of those. And it's no shame to be a top 20, but not #1 guy, either, which is where Mahomes is likely to end up. There are only 19 of those in the world.
 
Brady destroyed him in the playoffs. Mahomes is just another "He's great, but..." guy. And that's ok, because there are a lot of those. And it's no shame to be a top 20, but not #1 guy, either, which is where Mahomes is likely to end up. There are only 19 of those in the world.
Curious where do you have Mahomes ranked as of now? Top of your head
 
Curious where do you have Mahomes ranked as of now? Top of your head
Mahomo is lucky he plays in this weak Era of football with all these weak ass calls that go in his favor ever week. even 10 years ago that guy wouldnt win shit
 
Curious where do you have Mahomes ranked as of now? Top of your head

As a general rule, I start by keeping the top 8 here in place (though not in that same order, obviously, since Brady's the clear #1), and then have a scrum for #9-13 or #9-15 or so:


The definitive list: Top 10 NFL quarterbacks



And I don't yet see any reason to move Mahomes into that top 8, so I'd have him in that #9-15 scrum, which should be ok for any sane evaluator, since his cake's not fully baked yet). His failures against Brady in the playoffs loom large, since Brady's been the only real challenge to him in this weaker QB era.

And before the Mahomo starts on about his wins and all that, let me note that Brady took over a 5-11 team that was 0-2 to start the next year, while Mahomes has never played with a bad team, and the team he took over was already a team coming off of 11, 12, and 10 win seasons with 3 consecutive playoff appearances, and 4 double digit win years with playoff appearances in the 5 pre-Mahomes seasons.
 
Last edited:
As a general rule, I start by keeping the top 8 here in place (though not in that same order, obviously, since Brady's the clear #1), and then have a scrum for #9-13 or #9-15 or so:


The definitive list: Top 10 NFL quarterbacks



And I don't yet see any reason to move Mahomes into that top 8, so I'd have him in that #9-15 scrum, which should be ok for any sane evaluator, since his cake's not fully baked yet). His failures against Brady in the playoffs loom large, since Brady's been the only real challenge to him in this weaker QB era.

And before the Mahomo starts on about his wins and all that, let me note that Brady took over a 5-11 team that was 0-2 to start the next year, while Mahomes has never played with a bad team, and the team he took over was already a team coming off of 11, 12, and 10 win seasons with 3 consecutive playoff appearances, and 4 double digit win years with playoff appearances in the 5 pre-Mahomes seasons.
I agree. I think he is somewhere just outside of the top 10 currently. We will see how he does as his team continues to lose talent. They actually look very pedestrian this year but are finding ways to win because the league overall is crap ...
 
Mahomo is lucky he plays in this weak Era of football with all these weak ass calls that go in his favor ever week. even 10 years ago that guy wouldnt win shit
The level of cope and insecurities by you Brady lovers is really rich.

Don't worry is still going to take a few more years, but Mahomes is coming for that crown starting with the three peat.
 
The level of cope and insecurities by you Brady lovers is really rich.

Don't worry is still going to take a few more years, but Mahomes is coming for that crown starting with the three peat.
Uhm you gotta see why Kelce is washed
You ain't three peating if he's washed.
Worthy can't get open unless he's schemed open and Kermit struggling with Cover 2
 
Back
Top